| CMBA Past Champions |
| Year | Champion | Opponent |
|---|---|---|
| 1994 | Athletics * | Braves |
| 1995 | Athletics * | Brewers |
| 1996 | Athletics * | Angels |
| 1997 | Stars | Browns |
| 1998 | Blue Jays | Marlins |
| 1999 | Yankees | Browns |
| 2000 | Yankees | Cubs |
| 2001 | Browns | Tigers |
| 2002 | White Sox * | Athletics |
| 2003 | Marlins | Yankees |
| 2004 | Black Sox | Browns |
| 2005 | Vikings | Black Sox |
| 2006 | Marlins | Vikings |
| * Now called the Browns * Now called the Black Sox |
|